Say It Ain't So

I saw these on the TV screen last week. Old Navy was advertising this particular style during LOST -- and OMG, did you see LOST this past week? -- and I believe that I jumped higher, screamed louder, and got scared-er during the Old Navy ad that featured this horror than I did during the Stunning Conclusion To This Week's Episode.
Because, frankly, short-shorts rompers? Are enough to give anyone nightmares.
For the moment, let's leave out how you are possibly going to use public restrooms in this thing without dragging part or all of it into the toilet; that simply goes without saying.
Instead, concentrate on just how wrong the proportions of this thing are. The dropped waist! The below-elbow, but not three-quarters, sleeves! The teeny, weeny inseam of Doom! The very weirdly placed breast (or maybe, floating-rib) pocket!
Old Navy was advertising this using their skinniest and leggiest models, and they still all looked like a plate of Hot Mistake with a side of Mental Deficient. There is absolutely no way to wear this and be taken seriously. There are very few ways to wear this and not look as if you lost a particularly disastrous bet. (One would be wrapped around your head as a turban.)
And please, people, believe me. I know whereof I speak. I was a young teen, in Florida, in the early 1980s. I know all of the enticing forms that jumpsuits can take, and the few times that I 'experimented' -- well, let's just say that the flashbacks are debilitating. I can scarcely pass a tropical-print-floral rayon without vomiting, even today.
To sum up, this romper:
-- does not allow for the speedy completion of necessary bodily functions
-- makes you look like you're playing Tweedledee in the "Out of Africa" version of Alice in Wonderland
-- drains personal dignity faster than Jello body shots
-- is guaranteed to disflatter 99.99% of women (and most men, barring a few really in-shape go-go dancers)
-- doesn't even get the POCKETS right
Now, you're all grownups. You can wear what you like. But if I see you wearing this .... I will just be very disappointed, that's all.


67 Comments:
At Feb 18, 2008 8:41:00 AM,
Jen ~ MOMSPatterns said…
Tweedledee vs Out of Africa.. you made me guffaw!!!!
At Feb 18, 2008 8:46:00 AM,
Anonymous said…
Oh yes, jumpsuits... I was never daft enough to wear a short version, but I remember them all right. There are only so many ways to arrange pieces of cloth on a human body, so it was inevitable that someone would try to revive this style at some point.
At Feb 18, 2008 9:03:00 AM,
Marjie said…
I fast forward through commercials, so mercifully managed to miss this one during Lost, then was horrified this morning when it appeared in my email inbox! Wear as a turban? Maybe. How about remodeling it into a garage floor cleaning device?
At Feb 18, 2008 9:08:00 AM,
Jen said…
It looks slightly crumpled in this publicity photo, which means that if you wore it and had the temerity to try sitting down, the jumpsuit would punish you severely with nasty creases right across your lap.
I also think it needs a collar to give it the sort of safari suit finesse it would need to pull off that shade of beige.
At Feb 18, 2008 9:08:00 AM,
India said…
Oh, Erin! This is . . . eeeeeeeeeeeee!!
At Feb 18, 2008 9:13:00 AM,
Anne Douglas said…
This horrid disaster can only be superseded by the unmitigated, horrifying mess of the plus sized range. Barring a few items, ON really needs to turf their plus size designers, and actually get some designers in who are plus sized themselves, and put a stop to the babydoll tops, the square necklines, the slash pockets, excessively wide kimono sleeves... and those bermuda shorts...please!
It's great ON has such a big range of readily priced plus size clothing, it sucks big hairy donkey b...err a lot, that they ditched the in store presence, but gee, could it have been the horrid, horrid designs that came out in the plus range, that didn't come close to echoing the cute - and cheap - std size lines that might have not had it sell well?
At Feb 18, 2008 9:13:00 AM,
M said…
oh my yes-
I spotted something WORSE in a Paris department store window this past summer.
A shorts romper-suit with PUFFY BALLOON LEGS, a ruffly floral under shirt, and, the clincher, an over-sized RED BOW!
a picture of it can be found here:
http://e-laboratory.blogspot.com/
under the 2007 section greetings from paris. must be seen to be comprehended in all it's ghastly horror.
Just say "no" girls, just say "no"...
At Feb 18, 2008 9:30:00 AM,
Dilly said…
Oh my goodness - I just snorted tea across my computer screen at your wonderful way with words:
"Old Navy was advertising this using their skinniest and leggiest models, and they still all looked like a plate of Hot Mistake with a side of Mental Deficient"
I have SO got to use that description in conversation more often.
At Feb 18, 2008 9:35:00 AM,
Josie Thames said…
I'm so glad that someone was brave enough to speak out against the atrocious evil of jumpsuits.
And yet, as I was reading your post, all I could think of was how many high school girls will be giving into the unspeakable evil this summer.
It makes me shake my head in disgust.
At Feb 18, 2008 9:36:00 AM,
Vicki said…
I saw a similar version in a recent issue of Lucky. I had to comment on it as well . Are they ganging up on us to make us think we need these?
At Feb 18, 2008 9:55:00 AM,
Allison with Amai Unmei said…
thank you for this post! it totally made my morning :)
At Feb 18, 2008 10:03:00 AM,
vespabelle said…
jumpsuits are cute on little kids (and practical when they have crotch snaps!) but they can't be tan!
Old Navy's t-shirts seem to have gotten longer, sadly they are appear to be verging on unflattering. (I did not try them on, perhaps they're not so bad?)
At Feb 18, 2008 10:09:00 AM,
Chiara said…
Thank you sooo much for commenting on these. I was just as scandalized when I was last in Old Navy and saw them, and I cringe every time I think of someone wearing them with all seriousness.
At Feb 18, 2008 10:12:00 AM,
becky f. said…
I had a reversible blue/pink jumpsuit that I loved... when I was about 7.
The "pure evil" tag is right.
At Feb 18, 2008 10:39:00 AM,
oonaballoona said…
i didn't really know what horrified me about this jumper until you made it clear. great post, made me laugh out loud!
At Feb 18, 2008 10:41:00 AM,
tammyo said…
yeah, old navy is not hitting on a new concept here. babies have been wearing these forever...they're called "onesies".
At Feb 18, 2008 10:56:00 AM,
Lauren said…
That is just terribly frightening.
What's even more frightening is the price point which allows even MORE people to succumb to this atrocity.
And hello! I'm a new reader of your great blog. :)
At Feb 18, 2008 11:01:00 AM,
Ms. Nomer said…
yes, it has even struck in the kids department. the shirts are suck that i could give them a good stretch and go out in my new mini dress
At Feb 18, 2008 11:04:00 AM,
Viviene said…
Seems to me this fashion(for lack of a better word) is comparable to the Edsel of car models.
Gee, sure I'd just love to go back to the 1970s gymsuit from hell I wore at Washington High School in Phoenix where they tried to take our oh so thin bodies (yes I was thin back then) and make us look as androgynous as they could.
Or as my 10 and 9-year old daughters would say, "You have GOT to be kidding Mom."
At Feb 18, 2008 11:10:00 AM,
belphebe said…
This post has been removed by the author.
At Feb 18, 2008 11:12:00 AM,
belphebe said…
I certainly wouldn't wear this jumpsuit, but then, I don't have the figure for that dropped waist look. However, if jumpsuits are "in" again, I might be able to wear a cute one that I have tucked away in my closet; I just couldn't bear to get rid of it when I started gaining weight.
Of course, I'll have to lose a ton of weight first. And it will probably look terrible on me since I'm now an "old lady", but I want to be able to wear it again anyway.
But this thing? Definitely not flattering!
At Feb 18, 2008 11:36:00 AM,
Anonymous said…
i am contemplating buying one of these when old navy realizes they can't possibly sell them and have them priced down to a buck, picking out the inseam, and turning it into a shirt.
At Feb 18, 2008 12:04:00 PM,
Theresa said…
I hate old navy and never shop there. There stuff is so ill-fitting and biw apparently ugly to boot!
At Feb 18, 2008 12:08:00 PM,
Bean said…
Best hideous outfit commentary ever!! <3
At Feb 18, 2008 12:26:00 PM,
the_lazymilliner said…
Ahem...I would wear this. In fact Jennifer Lopez wore something similar a few years ago.
The only problem, I fear, is that this one-piece jumpsuit wouldn't be long enough in the torso for me.
I sew because I'm long-waisted and just about every blouse, top, sweater and t-shirt is too short for me.
That said, a jumpsuit like this isn't a high-priority for me to make. At least right now. A snowsuit is more likely at this juncture.
At Feb 18, 2008 12:51:00 PM,
sixties sewer said…
Obviously dangerous to read this on a wobbly chair. I nearly fell off this morning laughing. I had enough trouble wrestling a toddler into one the other day (have apparently lost my mothering edge) to want to avoid them for everyone, not just adults.
At Feb 18, 2008 1:12:00 PM,
TobyWollin said…
For those of us of "a certain age," these are not only the rompers of doom, they are also the prototype for the gym suits of doom, another totally unusable garment.
At Feb 18, 2008 1:30:00 PM,
Anonymous said…
In my skinny days (1970's) I wore a pale blue denim jump suit, with proper pants length legs, button down the front and afro style hair. The jump looked good (then) but what a nightmare in the Loo. I loved that damn thing though. Pretty sure my sisters and I had a few shorts style ones too!
At Feb 18, 2008 1:40:00 PM,
oracle said…
Er - I actually love jumpsuits. Some, anyway! I loved some in the 80's! But *always* with long pants and sleeves at flattering lengths. … I wouldn't (and couldn't) wear this one!
I've got a real favourite in mixed floral prints from La Cache (April Cornell) from around 1992 that I won't throw out, even though it got holey. It's really more of an overalls thing.
Anyway. Sometimes I wish for a really fun giant child-like jumpsuit in enlivening colours but with a re-designed crotch so that one can use a washroom without having to get totally undressed! I mean, how bad it can get in traditional jumpsuits if you're also wearing over it a buttoned-up coat with a scarf that ties closed the coat collar, plus a shoulder bag slung over the scarf and coat to boot! You practically have to strip right down and make sure not to "drag" any part of ANYTHING through the toilet! And there's not enough room to take all of that stuff off in a tiny stall, nor enough places to hang all your precious clothes as you shed them!
So I keep trying to figure out how to make a jumpsuit with a really stylish and fun trap door inspired by what the old longjohns had, or else with a big flap of fabric hanging down from the front that goes between the legs and its two wings spread out and come around the waist again from behind to tie in the front (a little like some Asian men's pants I've seen somewhere), or even with snaps like with onesies although I think the metal bits would be annoyingly cold against the skin. Haven't actually TRIED to make one yet, though!
Erin, I just loved your post today. I laughed right through it and read it again to repeat the enjoyment, and there's not a lot of things that make me laugh easily!
At Feb 18, 2008 1:48:00 PM,
meegiemoo said…
It does have one redeeming factor...
...it's not made of terrycloth.
At Feb 18, 2008 1:51:00 PM,
Anonymous said…
Definitiely gym-suit flashbacks here. Make it in an unflattering shade of forest-green and I will start to hear the butchy voice of gym teacher Sister Mary-Ellen.
At Feb 18, 2008 2:10:00 PM,
lorrwill said…
Anything that requires this level of undressing just to use the loo is pure fricking evil, alright.
Don't get me started about bringing back "who wears short-shorts"...
At Feb 18, 2008 2:58:00 PM,
lilymarlene said…
Just to say how much I enjoyed your post today.....and how much I agreed with it...!
At Feb 18, 2008 3:04:00 PM,
Kathleen said…
another Sign [as if we needed one] of the End Times, and a harbinger of the End of Civilization As We Know It.
The marketing team that added this to the product line should all be forced to wear these in public so that we can force them to endure our ridicule ;)
At Feb 18, 2008 3:31:00 PM,
Canine Diamond said…
I'm getting a wedgie just LOOKING at that.
At Feb 18, 2008 3:38:00 PM,
Toiling Ant said…
I laughed so hard I got hiccups.
At Feb 18, 2008 4:10:00 PM,
stacysews said…
I liked how Old Navy called this their "Urban Explorer" collection - it reminds me of that Seinfeld episode where Elaine is in charge of the J Peterman catalog and makes the disastrous "Urban Sombrero"....
At Feb 18, 2008 4:14:00 PM,
Janice said…
Omg, that is some serious comedy. Thanks for the laugh, I haven't laughed that hard in a few days, lol, and I was in my college library, too! AH! I could hardly breathe!!!
At Feb 18, 2008 4:35:00 PM,
Anonymous said…
I wouldn't buy a jumpsuit because it just wouldn't fit right. But you can be damn sure I'm going to make a couple. I'm tickled they are back in.
Melody
At Feb 18, 2008 4:53:00 PM,
nancy in portland said…
i can't believe this post generated so many responses.... it seems the fear of jumpsuits might be a good topic for psychology today...
At Feb 18, 2008 5:13:00 PM,
Laceflower said…
I had a jumpsuit back in the seventies, I used it for a weight gage. If I could get it on I was doing OK. Haaaaaahhhhhhaaaa made me come out of lurkdom. Love your blog Erin.
At Feb 18, 2008 5:15:00 PM,
India said…
Yeah, what meegiemoo said. I have a pretty low Go Fug Yourself tolerance, but I just can't stop thinking of this picture: Chloe Sofugny
At Feb 18, 2008 5:40:00 PM,
jackie said…
You left out the only truly proper way to wear this - with a pair of Uggs, of course. In July.
At Feb 18, 2008 6:14:00 PM,
A. said…
this is also a perfect example of the kind of thing old navy would astutely decide to offer in their miniscule plus size range. Not pretty dresses, not cute trench coats, not practical tops, but a 1 inch inseam romper. with belt.
mark my words. mark my words.
At Feb 18, 2008 6:36:00 PM,
What-I-Found said…
Eeeewwww!
Has anybody else noticed how Old Navy does this...they take some weird twist and advertise it so much that somebody, somewhere starts buying it. Striped sweater vests, cuffed capris, odd fleeced things...all sorts of strange items...but this is the strangest.
And we will see young things walking around on the streets in this. And she'll think she looks great. Oh my.
At Feb 18, 2008 7:02:00 PM,
Zoltar Panaflex said…
I used to wear stuff like that when I painted apartments.
Only mine was make of Tyvek.
Since when has anyone over the age of 12 bought anything from Old Navy?
The Gap messed up when they hurried to close Forth & Towne, then wondered why they couldn't get any women 30+ to buy their merchandise.
At Feb 18, 2008 7:44:00 PM,
Mary Sue said…
The commercials made me all but barf, too.
Then, today, I saw someone wearing one.
She was an attractive enough girl. Too bad it looked like she was wearing a wrinkled potato sack!
(Have you noticed that even in the commericals they are wrinkled?!)
At Feb 18, 2008 7:51:00 PM,
Nancy Bea Miller said…
Wow, unsexy short shorts! Who'd have thought it possible? Old Navy has really broadened my horizons here!
That floating rib pocket does add a certain je ne sais quoi, perhaps a touch of alien chic?
At Feb 18, 2008 8:21:00 PM,
enc said…
I did a post about these about a week ago titled: "The Horror."
They're appalling. I saw them in the store, and they were appalling.
At Feb 18, 2008 9:20:00 PM,
Anonymous said…
Dye it dark blue and it could pass for the Jr. High PE costume I was forced to wear back in 1970!
The ONLY jumpsuit I ever wore was also in the 70's when I a darn good shape; it had white, flowing pants, and a triangle cut out over the tummy (not the navel), the upper fabric was white with yellow sunflowers and bees.
Cute as a bugs ear I was.
*sigh*
I'm turning 50 on Thursday.....
Tru
At Feb 18, 2008 9:23:00 PM,
Lisa said…
Yeah, it's a wreck. Let's talk about LOST. :-)
At Feb 18, 2008 10:16:00 PM,
jennifer said…
for the ON phobes,
it is being totally re-merchandised as we speak.
goodby denim, hello H&M style junior wear.
p.s. I made this in 1971, when it was called "hot pants" and a button front midi-skirt to wear over it (worn mostly un-buttoned), in that home ec class where yesterday's sewing quiz on ditto paper was handed out to test our sewing know-how.
At Feb 19, 2008 7:32:00 AM,
Anonymous said…
Further evidence that Gap, Inc. is not an arbiter of style. The designers must be sitting back having a good laugh at the schmucks who buy this stuff simply because Gap says so.
At Feb 19, 2008 7:36:00 AM,
HouseMouse said…
So, in 1984 I had this cute white cotton shorts jumpsuit with multicolor neon "paint spatters" like a Jackson Pollock design. I was 12, petite and thin, and the look worked back then. The suit had a 5 or 6 inch inseam and little cap sleeves, so the proportion was correct, and for the 80s, it was flattering. Still h@!! in the bathroom which I remember well.
This jumpsuit looks like a safari design gone horribly wrong. And I'm 36 now. My 9-month-old is the onesie wearer these days, and even those wouldn't work without the crotch snaps.
At Feb 19, 2008 9:28:00 AM,
Anonymous said…
tropical-print-floral rayon!!!!!
My first job 1984 Jo-Ann Fabrics, sold, sewed, and wore ALOT of that stuff.....! As for jumpsuits, I just ignore them, they will go away, they always do.
At Feb 19, 2008 2:25:00 PM,
DivaJean said…
I much prefer the Out of Africa safari look. Circa 1986, I was scooping up long safari skirts like no tomorrow. I would wear them today- or maybe this summer...
At Feb 19, 2008 2:44:00 PM,
colleen said…
Oh yes, the jumpsuit. I had a few. I'm trying hard to forget.
I haven't bought anything from the GAP in at least 10 years. To me, they went wrong when they stopped focusing on the preppy, casual basics.
At Feb 19, 2008 3:55:00 PM,
Theresa said…
Ever notice there are more posts generated wen we HATE something,as oppsoed to things we love.
Everyone's posts of jumpsuits past are bringing back some PAINFUL 80s memories. I even had one that looked liek a tuxedo. I think I had 5, yes count them , 5 jumpsuits. Good Lord what was I thinking! I am so glad my taste has improves. (one was indian torquise with light pink piping and an obi belt....I'm not making this up.)
At Feb 19, 2008 4:19:00 PM,
Maile said…
I suspect that these are being marketed to boost sales in adult diapers - coming soon in designer colors, i.e. GhAGki. Until the designer diapers catch on, (ooh! Depends Thongs!), victims should be allowed to undress and pee in any ON dressing room.
At Feb 19, 2008 4:45:00 PM,
kalamari said…
the best part (because there are soooo many good parts) is that it is available up through size 3x, woohoo!!!
At Feb 19, 2008 9:05:00 PM,
Leticia said…
I've read all the comments and was appalled to see that nobody pointed out that not even a go-go girl with the best of bodies would look good on this. Maybe a skinny model could not look fat, but she would surely look frumpy.
At Feb 20, 2008 4:36:00 PM,
Anonymous said…
These would look fine on the bodies and proportions for which they were originally designed:
Chimpanzees.
Seriously; look at those proportions! Made for a primate, but not one of us!
I actually admit to hanging on to a lovely jumpsuit, in the event I can get back into it: black wook jersey, with a dashing leather insert at the waist. *sigh*
And, Divajean, I second the Out of Africa safari look, with skirts! And hats! And lace-edged linen blouses!
Not this ... this ... this chimp change.
La BellaDonna
At Feb 20, 2008 8:03:00 PM,
Andrea said…
A nice summary, and certainly more coherent than my horrified thought upon seeing said rompers -- which was basically, "Get the behind me, Satan!"
At Feb 20, 2008 8:14:00 PM,
Andrea said…
Uh, I meant "Get thee" obviously... sometimes the brain and the typing do not align...
At Feb 21, 2008 4:10:00 PM,
Bettsi McComb said…
Yes, it is truly an atrocity! I had a few cotton jumpsuits in the 80's. I had to wear suits to my job (at Casual Corner!) and after work I would slip into a lovely little jumpsuit that felt like nothing and cute little espadrilles. I too loved the Out of Africa look. Remember how big it was at Limited?
At Feb 23, 2008 11:11:00 PM,
Diva said…
I like this style actually but hey to each his own.
At Mar 22, 2008 10:56:00 AM,
Kerri said…
This is the best clothing rant I can ever remember reading. You are my hero. How do I sign up?
Post a Comment
<< Home